Details

Published: 27 May 2013

The researchers of the Virtual Acoustics Research group, Dr. Sakari Tervo, Dr. Jukka Pätynen, and PhD Philip Robinson, M.Sc. Antti Kuusinen, and M.Sc. Aki Haapaniemi, received the Matti Karjalainen-Trust Award for their research work on concert hall acoustics. The Matti Karjalainen-trust committee considered that the researchers have done an exceptional work on the development of the measurement and analysis tools for concert hall acoustics. The award was given to the researchers in 22nd of May 2013 in Turku in Akustiikkapäivät 2013, a Finnish Acoustical Society Meeting.  

Details

Published: 07 May 2013

Introduction

This spring, members of the Virtual Acoustics Team conducted a Media Technology Seminar: Applied Data Analysis and Visualization. The concept of the course was to explore new methods to visualize spatial acoustic room impulse responses. Students from the media technology and computer science departments, some without prior acoustics knowledge, brought diverse skills and expertise to the seminar and produced a variety of animated and interactive graphics to illustrate the high-dimensional data.  

The data set is a collection of acoustic room impulse responses that the Virtual Acoustics Team measured during a tour of 10 of Europe's great concert halls, in November of 2012. Measurements were conducted with 36 loudspeakers on the stage of each hall, and for multiple listening positions in the audience areas. The receiver was a 6 microphone array, which allowed post-processing to determine the direction of arrival of the sound at each instant in the impulse response.  This processing was conducted prior to handing the data over to the students. Thus, the data were multi-dimensional, at least 8 dimensions could be represented. Students were encouraged to explore visualizing source positions, receiver positions, three-dimensional spatial aspects, temporal development, frequency characteristics, and comparisons between halls.  

 While students were expected to have basic knowledge of computer graphics, their backgrounds were diverse. Some were members of the Virtual Acoustics Team and were well versed in room acoustics techniques, while others had no previous experience with acoustics, but brought programming, computer graphics, or other expertise to the group. For this reason, students were paired in an attempt to maximize synergies. Specific methods or software were not dictated in order to prevent limiting the possible outcomes. 

The first task for each student was to produce a 3D model of one of the concert halls. This exercise allowed the students to become familiar with the spaces the measured data were taken from, and the models provided a context for the data visualizations.  The students were encouraged to incorporate the visualizations into the models to provide an environmental context for the data, and this was accomplished with various degrees of success.

The second task was to create an animation or interactive graphic to represent the data.  The students produced several novel visualizations, which are displayed here.

Lateral plane energy distribution in octave bands. Aki Haapaniemi and Petri Leskinen

This visualization demonstrates the lateral energy, integrated over a given time window, and divided into octave bands. It is novel because, while time-frequency plots and, spatial energy plots have been utilized in the past, spatial frequency plots are much less common in room acoustics. The data disk is located within the hall at the receiver position, and the energy from each direction is highlighted in green. Octave bands are illustrated in concentric circles, with the lowest frequencies at the center. Interactive sliders allow the viewer to examine various time windows.

Nested tesselated spheres. Petri Leskinen and Aki Haapaniemi

Similar to the previous one, this visualization places a representation of the sound energy within the concert hall model, at the receiver location. Here, the data are represented in broadband, rather than in octave bands, but several time windows can be nested to examine the early and late sound responses simultaneously. The graphic is interactive to allow the viewer to fly around and zoom the response.

Dynamic sound arrivals. Morley Zan-Bi and Antti Kuusinen

This visualization is based on the open-source package Processing. The concept is to visualize the time and direction of arriving sound with parallelepipeds that converge on the listening position. In this image the sound source is to the right and the listener position is at the center. The direct sound is indicated in red, the early reflections in green, and the late reverberation in blue.  The size of each particle and its final distance from the receiver position represent the strength of the reflection at that particular time instant. The visualization is animated to allow the viewer to watch the development of the room response over time, and interactive to allow the user to pan and zoom around the response for a complete view.

Spherical Energy. Hannu Järvinen and Timo Rutanen

The final visualization takes a similar approach and animates the sound arrival strengths and directions. Frames include approximately 1 ms of data and are overlapped 50%. The particles are positioned at a distance from the receiver proportional to their strength and in the direction of their arrival.

Conclusion

A design studio approach to the data visualization course allowed the students to use their own creativity to illustrate a large database of high dimensional data.  The measured concert hall data provided and interesting and challenging context for this exploration. The resulting novel visualization techniques may have further utility for room acoustics research and are a tangible and useful course outcome. 

Details

Published: 29 April 2013

Virtual Acoustics Team is conducting a workshop Capturing the Acoustics of Concert Halls with a Loudspeaker Orchestra on Saturday, May 4, 10:30 — 12:30 in AES 134, Rome, in Auditorium Loyola

The workshop will include presentations from Prof. Lokki, and Drs. Pätynen and Tervo, on the subjective and objective evaluation of concert halls.

In the last 5 years, Virtual acoustics team has measured 20 concert halls with a loudspeaker orchestra, which consists of 34 loudspeakers. In the measurements, spatial room impulse responses are measured from the loudspeakers to a microphone array. These impulse responses are further processed for analysis and synthesis purposes. The presentations will include a detailed description of these techniques and practicalities related to the measurements.

Details

Published: 15 March 2013

The Virtual Acoustics team has recently worked hard to finalize six papers that will be presented next June in International Symposium on Room Acoustics (ISRA 2013). We are really looking forward to a great conference in Toronto, Canada.

Two of the papers deal with room acoustics modeling. Haapaniemi et al. [1] discuss about reflection of sound from layered structures often used in concert halls. The results show how sound is attenuated at some frequencies and how well such structures diffuse sound. Robinson et al. [2] introduce a project in which best shapes of side walls and side balconies are searched with automatic optimization of geometry. 

Tervo et al. [3] extend a recently published Spatial Decomposition Method to perform the analysis on frequency bands. The paper also shows visualizations on sound energy distribution in two concert halls. Pätynen et al. [4] show that when an orchestra plays in fortissimo the spectrum of sound is quite different than in pianissimo. Thus, the music has non-linear characteristics that are earlier neglected in room acoustics studies. Moreover, human (spatial) hearing is also highly non-linear, another aspect that should be considered seriously in concert hall acoustics studies.

Kuusinen et al. [5] analyse the behavior of individual assessors in our recent studies (IVP1 in 2011 and IVP2 in 2012) on concert hall acoustics with individual vocabulary profiling technique. The analysis reveals that subjects behave quite differently when they are creating individual discriminating attributes for comparison of concert halls. Finally, Lokki gathers, in his keynote paper [6], the current knowledge of the team by presenting some interesting time-frequency and spatiotemporal analysis of famous European concert halls that we have recently measured.

@inproceedings{haa13isra,
	address = "Toronto, Canada",
	author = "A. Haapaniemi and A. Southern and T. Lokki",
	booktitle = "International Symposium on Room Acoustics (ISRA 2013)",
	date-added = "2013-03-13 17:35:54 +0200",
	date-modified = "2013-03-13 17:35:54 +0200",
	keywords = "Wave-based models, Concert hall acoustics",
	month = "June 9-11",
	title = "A finite-difference time-domain investigation of reflections from layered wall structures",
	year = 2013
}

@inproceedings{rob13isra,
	address = "Toronto, Canada",
	author = "P. W. Robinson and S. Siltanen and T. Lokki and L. Savioja",
	booktitle = "International Symposium on Room Acoustics (ISRA 2013)",
	date-added = "2013-03-13 17:35:54 +0200",
	date-modified = "2013-03-13 17:35:54 +0200",
	keywords = "Concert hall acoustics",
	month = "June 9-11",
	title = "Concert hall geometry optimization with parametric modeling tools and wave-based acoustic simulations",
	year = 2013
}

@inproceedings{ter13isra,
	address = "Toronto, Canada",
	author = {S. Tervo and J. P{\"a}tynen and T. Lokki},
	booktitle = "International Symposium on Room Acoustics (ISRA 2013)",
	date-added = "2013-03-13 17:35:54 +0200",
	date-modified = "2013-03-13 17:35:54 +0200",
	keywords = "Room acoustic analysis",
	month = "June 9-11",
	title = "Spatial analysis of concert hall impulse responses",
	year = 2013
}

@inproceedings{pat13isra,
	address = "Toronto, Canada",
	author = {J. P{\"a}tynen and S. Tervo and T. Lokki},
	booktitle = "International Symposium on Room Acoustics (ISRA 2013)",
	date-added = "2013-03-13 17:35:54 +0200",
	date-modified = "2013-03-13 17:35:54 +0200",
	keywords = "Concert hall acoustics, Room acoustic analysis",
	month = "June 9-11",
	title = "Binaural dynamic responsiveness in concert halls",
	year = 2013
}

@inproceedings{kuu13isra,
	address = "Toronto, Canada",
	author = "A. Kuusinen and T. Lokki",
	booktitle = "International Symposium on Room Acoustics (ISRA 2013)",
	date-added = "2013-03-13 17:35:54 +0200",
	date-modified = "2013-03-13 17:35:54 +0200",
	keywords = "Concert hall acoustics",
	month = "June 9-11",
	title = "Individual differences in quality judgments and preferences of concert hall acoustics",
	year = 2013
}

@inproceedings{lok13isra,
	address = "Toronto, Canada",
	author = "T. Lokki",
	booktitle = "International Symposium on Room Acoustics (ISRA 2013)",
	date-added = "2013-03-13 17:35:54 +0200",
	date-modified = "2013-03-13 17:35:54 +0200",
	keywords = "Concert hall acoustics, Room acoustic analysis",
	month = "June 9-11",
	title = "Throw away that standard and listen: your two ears work better",
	year = 2013
}